The Problem with “Love Yourself First”: An Examination of Toxic Positivity
The frequently repeated mantra, “Love yourself first,” has become a staple in pop psychology and self-help circles. It’s plastered on motivational posters, echoed in social media posts, and recited by well-meaning friends and family. Yet, beneath its seemingly empowering veneer lies a problematic message that can be damaging, especially for individuals grappling with trauma and mental health issues.
Welcome to #AskMadelaine, where we fearlessly explore the questions swirling in your mind about life, the world, and our very existence. Have a burning question for Madelaine? Share it with us at info@madelainevallin.com, using the subject line “Modern Visdom” (it’s not misspelled—it’s Swedish for wisdom). We can’t wait to hear from you.
To dismiss the notion of self-love entirely would be shortsighted. Indeed, cultivating a healthy self-esteem and sense of self-worth is crucial for personal growth and well-being. However, the way in which this advice is often presented oversimplifies a complex emotional landscape and fails to acknowledge the external factors that shape our self-perception.
For many, the journey toward self-love is not a solitary endeavour but rather a communal effort. Human beings are inherently social creatures, wired to seek connection and validation from others. From infancy, we crave the attention and affection of caregivers, laying the foundation for our future relationships and self-image.
Unfortunately, not everyone is fortunate enough to receive unconditional love and support from their early caregivers. Those who have experienced abuse or neglect may struggle to develop a positive self-concept, grappling with feelings of worthlessness and inadequacy. In such cases, the simplistic prescription to “love yourself first” rings hollow and invalidating.
Moreover, the emphasis on self-love can inadvertently perpetuate harmful myths about resilience and individual responsibility. It implies that one should be able to overcome life’s challenges through sheer force of will, disregarding the systemic barriers and societal inequalities that shape our experiences. This individualistic ethos overlooks the crucial role of community and collective support in fostering resilience and healing.
Furthermore, the notion of self-love can be weaponised against marginalised individuals, particularly those who have been marginalised or oppressed. It places the burden of healing squarely on the shoulders of the individual, absolving society of its responsibility to address systemic injustices and create a more equitable world.
One area of concern is how excessive optimism can influence decision-making processes. Research published at the National Library of Medicine (2015) showed that optimistic individuals were more likely to engage in risky behaviours and make poor decisions, particularly when faced with uncertain outcomes. This suggests that unrealistic optimism may lead individuals to underestimate risks and overestimate potential rewards, potentially compromising their well-being in the long run.
Moreover, as a mental health professional, I have witnessed this problem firsthand in clients. Many individuals, especially those with histories of trauma or abuse, struggle to internalise the concept of self-love due to deep-seated feelings of unworthiness and inadequacy. For them, the notion of “loving yourself first” feels like an unattainable ideal rather than a practical solution. Instead, they require compassionate support and validation from others to begin the journey towards self-acceptance.
Ultimately, the pursuit of self-love should not be seen as a substitute for genuine human connection and support. It is not a panacea for all of life’s struggles, nor should it be wielded as a moralistic cudgel to judge those who are still navigating their own journeys towards self-acceptance.
Instead, let us reframe the conversation around self-love to acknowledge its complexity and nuance. Let us recognise that loving oneself is not a destination but a continuous process shaped by our relationships, experiences, and environment. And let us strive to create communities that uplift and empower each other, recognising that true healing and transformation require collective effort and solidarity.
Reference: Shepperd, J. A., Waters, E. A., Weinstein, N. D., & Klein, W. M. (2015). A primer on unrealistic optimism. Current directions in psychological science, 24(3), 232-237.
🌿 I Frid, Madelaine
PLUS – Whenever you’re ready, there are 2 ways we can work together:
- Sign up for one of our current courses at ASHC and get taught by my team of advisors and me. All our courses are internationally and nationally industry-approved and will equip you with all the tools to open up your own professional private practice.
- Apply for one of only three spots as my private client. Mentorship for Holistic Mental Health Practitioners (1), Mentorship for High Performers (2).
Leave a Reply